Windows IT Pro is the authoritative and independent resource for windows nt, windows 2000, windows 2003, windows xp. Features a collection of resources and magazines for windows IT professionals.
  
  
  Advanced Search 


November 2005

Just Browsing

Find out how 4 popular Internet browsers stack up
RSS
Subscribe to Windows IT Pro | See More Internet Articles Here | Reprints | Or get the Monthly Online Pass—only $5.95 a month!

Netscape 8.0
Netscape 8.0 is primarily based on Firefox source code. However, Netscape lets users choose whether to use the Firefox or IE rendering engines. If you visit a Web site designed specifically for IE, you can quickly switch to the IE rendering engine to gain any necessary site functionality.

Most of the features you find in Firefox are available in Netscape, so I won't repeat them. However, you should be aware of one limitation: Netscape runs only on Windows platforms.

On the surface, Netscape's UI is much like Firefox's, although I found it to be somewhat cluttered and unpleasant to the eye. Even so, a notable security difference exists under the hood. Netscape offers security via Site Controls, which are similar to IE's Security Zones. You can define master settings that determine how the browser will behave for each site you visit. There are four master settings: I Trust This Site, I'm Not Sure, I Don't Trust This Site, and Local Files (equivalent to IE's Trusted Sites, Internet, Restricted Sites, and Local Intranet zones, respectively). For each zone, you can enable or disable various Web features, such as Java, JavaScript, cookies, and pop-up windows. And because Netscape supports the IE rendering engine, you can also specify whether to allow use of ActiveX controls. Figure 3 shows how Netscape takes the zone concept a step further than IE by letting you adjust Site Controls in a given zone on a per-site basis.

Another part of Site Controls is Trust Ratings, which when enabled cause the browser to rely on a third party to determine whether to trust a Web site's content and enter sensitive information at that site. Trust Ratings uses a catalog maintained by a third party and can be refreshed hourly, daily, or weekly. Just who this third party is remains unknown to me; my inquiries regarding this question (and future browser features) went unanswered.

Netscape also supports a nifty multibar feature, which lets you configure as many as 10 toolbars that can be accessed quickly. The feature also lets you scroll RSS headlines in toolbars. And like the other browsers I tested, Netscape supports an auto-fill feature that can save form field information and fill in those fields when you revisit a Web page.

Overall,Netscape is a slick Web browser. Even so, I prefer Firefox for day-to-day Web surfing, primarily because there aren't many extensions or themes available for Netscape. (Netscape uses the same extension architecture as Firefox uses, so many of those extensions would probably work, but you might need to edit the extensions' code manually.)

Netscape 8.0
Contact: Netscape Communications * 650-254-1900
Web: http://browser.netscape.com/ns8
Price: Free, with the ability to purchase premium support and versions for mobile devices
Summary
Pros: Uses both Firefox and IE rendering engines; excellent security features; multiplatform support
Cons: Runs on Windows platforms only; no support for AD or Group Policy
Rating: 4 out of 5
Recommendation: This IE alternative offers the best of Firefox and IE in one browser interface. A good product if you don't care too much about extensions and themes.


Internet Explorer 7.0 Beta 1
Microsoft's next version of IE, IE 7.0, was still in Beta 1 testing at the time of this writing. IE 7.0 promises to be a vast improvement over earlier versions of the browser.

Last I heard, IE 7.0 might actually be released as an update to XP (by the end of 2005) but will definitely ship as a standard part of the upcoming Windows Vista OS. On the downside, the fact that Microsoft considers the browser to be an official part of the OS means that IE 7.0 will be back-ported for use only on Windows Server 2003 and XP. Microsoft said that porting the browser to earlier Windows versions would be too difficult.

It's been a long time since Microsoft added any significant non-security features to the browser. As such, IE has a lot of catching up to do with the likes of Opera, Firefox, and Netscape, and the company isn't wasting any time in mirroring many of those browsers' most appealing features.

New IE features will include support for RSS and Atom feeds so that other applications on the desktop will be able to share those feeds. IE 7.0 will also make it simple for users to delete all Web use history, Web form data and passwords, temporary files, and cookies. Other improvements include better compliance with widely accepted Web standards such as Cascading Style Sheets (CSS), which means the browser will be more compatible with progressive Web sites.

IE 7.0 will also have a slightly different UI than its predecessors, finally offering direct support for tabbed browsing along with a search engine located near the address bar (a feature similar to the other browsers I tested). A key feature of IE is that, at the time of this writing, it's the only browser that you can thoroughly control by using Active Directory (AD) and Group Policy, which makes it attractive for midsized and large enterprises.

Like the other browsers in this report, IE is customizable. Functionality can be added by using registry entries and Dynamic HTML (DHTML) or by developing add-ons in C, Pascal, and other programming languages. Although far more add-ons are available for Firefox, IE users enjoy a wide selection of add-ons that introduce various types of functionality, such as the MSN Search Toolbar, Google toolbar, Yahoo! Toolbar, weather site interfaces, mass-downloading tools, Voice over IP (VoIP) tools, and more.

As expected, IE 7.0 will offer stronger security. That's good news because IE has long been a prime target of vulnerability hunters and intruders, and as such has seen many security patches over the years. In fact, Beta 1 is focused primarily on security. But there is a caveat associated with the improved security: You won't get the full advantage of the final release version without upgrading to Windows Vista.

One new security feature will be No Add-ons Mode, which causes the browser to operate with all ActiveX controls, toolbars, and add-ons disabled. A new add-ons manager, which is somewhat similar to the managers in Firefox and Netscape, will let users view installed add-ons and ActiveX controls and enable or disable any of them with a click of the mouse.

Another security feature will be protection against phishing attacks. When you visit a site, the browser will perform a real-time URL lookup against a database (maintained by Microsoft) of known and suspected phishing sites. If you're visiting such a site, the browser will warn you, as Figure 4 shows. This feature is similar to the functionality found in Netscape's Trust Ratings.

IE will also provide a Protected Mode, in which the browser will be unable to modify files and system settings. In this mode, the browser will be isolated from the OS and will communicate with the underlying OS by using a broker process. In addition, Protected Mode will severely restrict COM objects and the browser will be able to write only to the temporary Internet files directory. These features will help protect the system against infiltration by various forms of malware.

IE 7.0 is only in its preliminary testing stages and therefore additional features aren't set in stone yet. Microsoft says that it expects the browser to undergo changes continually until the final product is released.

Internet Explorer 7.0 Beta 1
Contact: Microsoft
Web: http://www.microsoft.com/windows/IE
Price: Free for beta testers and will eventually be free for users of Windows 2003 and XP
Summary
Pros: Numerous security enhancements, tabbed browsing, RSS reader, improved Web standards compliance
Cons: Runs on Windows 2003 and XP only; not as compliant with Web standards as competing browsers
Rating: 4 out of 5
Recommendation: This browser is great for companies that rely on AD and Group Policy to manage browser configuration and for anyone who regularly uses Web sites that include ActiveX controls.


Summing Up
All four of the browsers I tested are powerful, flexible, and packed with features. Each browser is a reasonable choice for everyday use, depending on whether you prefer open-source products or need AD integration. I prefer Firefox because of its huge base of community support, multiplatform support, and available features.

End of Article

   Previous  1  [2]  Next  


Reader Comments

You must log on before posting a comment.

If you don't have a username & password, please register now.




Top Viewed ArticlesView all articles
Accessing Database Data with ADO

...

Friday at PASS Europe 2006

Kevin talks about the closing day of the event and shares a funny Microsoft film. ...

The Memory-Optimization Hoax

Don't believe the hype. At best, RAM optimizers have no effect. At worst, they seriously degrade performance. ...


News and Analysis Whitepapers MIMO Wireless LAN PHY Layer (RF) Operation & Measurement Application Note 1509

IT Industry Trends 2005 Study

The Who, What, Why, and Where of IT Events and Trade Shows

Related Events Check out our list of Free Email Newsletters!

Related News and Analysis Resources Become a VIP member of the Windows IT Pro community!
Get it all with the VIP CD and VIP access. A $500+ value for only $279!

Subscribe to Windows IT Pro!
Solve your toughest technical problems with our experts and access 10,000 + articles online. 30% off

Monthly Online Pass - Only $5.95!
Get instant access to 10,000+ articles from Windows IT Pro Magazine!

TechNet Virtual Labs
Evaluate and test Microsoft's newest products.

Job Openings in IT


ADS BY GOOGLE SPONSORED LINKS FEATURED LINKS

Maximize your SharePoint Investment – 8 Cities
Discover best practices and tips for both architecting and administering SharePoint. Early Bird Price of $99 through Sept 15th.

Find a new job now on the all new IT Job Hound!
Search jobs, post your resume, and set up job e-mail alerts!

Master SharePoint with 3 eLearning Seminars
Learn how to build a better SharePoint infrastructure and enable powerful collaboration with MVPs Dan Holme and Michael Noel. Register today!

Top Tools for Virtualization Disaster Recovery & Replication
View this web seminar on August 14th to learn about two tools that will result in faster backup and restore with P2V disaster recovery.

SharePointConnections Conference Fall 2008
Don’t miss the premier event for Microsoft IT Professionals in Las Vegas, November 10-13. Register and book your room by August 25 and receive a FREE room night (based on a three night minimum stay).

VMworld 2008 - Sign Up Today!
Join your peers on September 15-18 at The Venetian Hotel in Las Vegas as VMware hosts VMworld 2008, the leading Virtualization event.



Increase Application Performance
Free White Paper by Editor's Best winner, Texas Memory Systems.

Microsoft® Tech•Ed EMEA 2008 IT Professionals
Advance your thinking with new ideas and practical real-world solutions at Microsoft’s FIVE day technical infrastructure conference 3-7 Nov., 2008. Register before 26 September 2008 to save €300.

Order Your SQL Fundamentals CD Today!
Learn how to use SQL Server, understand Office integration techniques and dive into the essentials of SQL Express and Visual Basic with this free SQL Fundamentals CD.

Are You Really Compliant with Software Regulations?
View this web seminar that will help you with compliance best practices and check out a management solution to assure that you won’t be in jeopardy of an audit.

Virtualization Congress Oct. 14-16 in London
Don't miss Virtualization Congress, the premiere EMEA conference dedicated to hardware, OS and application virtualization. Oct. 14-16.
Windows IT Pro Home Register FAQ for Windows WinInfo News
Europe Edition About Us Contact Us/Customer Service Media Kit Affiliates / Licensing  
SQL Server Magazine Office & SharePoint Pro Windows Dev Pro IT Job Hound ITTV
IT Library Technical Resources Directory Connected Home Windows Excavator Windows SuperSite 
 
 Windows IT Pro is a Division of Penton Media Inc.
 Copyright © 2008 Penton Media, Inc., All rights reserved. Terms and Use | Privacy Statement | Reprints and Licensing